Skip to content

  • Cookies + Toffee
  • Merch
  • About
  • Contact
  • Log in
Mackinac Island Cookie Co.
  • Cookies + Toffee
  • Merch
  • About
  • Contact
  • 0
Mackinac Island Cookie Co.
0 Cart
4 Pack ($36)
Regular price $36.00
$36.00
Birthday Cookie
Regular price $11.00
$11.00
Cherry Chocolate Chunk
Regular price $9.00
$9.00
Coffee Toffee Cookie
Regular price $10.00
$10.00
Coffee Toffee Cookie
Regular price $10.00
$10.00
Cookie Bike Hats
Regular price $38.00
$38.00
Cookie Hat
Regular price $38.00
$38.00
Cookie Hoodie
Regular price $100.00
$100.00
Cookie Tester Tee
Regular price $40.00
$40.00
Diana LCI Mockneck Sweatshirt
Regular price $65.00
$65.00
Diana Mockneck Sweatshirt - Mackinac
Regular price $72.00
$72.00
Dutch Chocolate Chunk
Regular price $9.00
$9.00
English Toffee
Regular price $21.95
$21.95
Flag Sweatshirt - Mack/Navy
Regular price $62.00
$62.00
Gift Card
From Regular price $10.00
From $10.00
Gluten Free Breakfast
Regular price $9.00
$9.00
Gluten Free Chocolate Chip (New!)
Regular price $9.00
$9.00
Hestia Vest - MI
Regular price $115.00
$115.00
Hopkins Crew - MI
Regular price $140.00
$140.00
ISea Sunglasses
Regular price $34.00
$34.00
Knit Mackinac Island Blanket
Regular price $112.00
$112.00
L2 Applique Teeshirt Hoodie
Regular price $72.00
$72.00
Lakegirl Boat Hair Tee
Regular price $42.00
$42.00
Lakegirl Knit Sweater
Regular price $56.00
$56.00
Lakegirl Paddle Hat
Regular price $32.00
$32.00
Lakegirl White Crew
Regular price $76.00
$76.00
Latte
From Regular price $6.00
From $6.00
Les Cheneaux American Flag Sweatshirt - Navy
Regular price $62.00
$62.00
Les Cheneaux American Flag Sweatshirt - Oat
Regular price $62.00
$62.00
Les Cheneaux Cottage Sweatshirt - Blue
Regular price $56.00
$56.00
Les Cheneaux Cottage Sweatshirt - Yellow
Regular price $56.00
$56.00
Les Cheneaux Signal Flag Sweatshirt - Red
Regular price $62.00
$62.00
Les Cheneax Signal Flag Sweatshirt - Navy
Regular price $62.00
$62.00
Long Sleeve Cookie Tee
Regular price $50.00
$50.00
Mackinac Clubhouse Cap
Regular price $38.00
$38.00
Mackinac Island Bike Tote
Regular price $15.00
$15.00
Mackinac Island Cookie Co. Gift Card
From Regular price $10.00
From $10.00
Mackinac Island Cookie Co. Mug
Regular price $15.00
$15.00
Mackinac Island Heart Hat
Regular price $36.00
$36.00
Mackinac Island Lighthouse Baseball Cap
Regular price $42.00
$42.00
Mackinac Island Lighthouse Sweatshirt
Regular price $125.00
$125.00
Mackinac Monster (New!)
Regular price $9.00
$9.00
Mackinac Prep Sweater
Regular price $112.00
$112.00
Mackinac Striped Sailor Sweater
Regular price $112.00
$112.00
Marlow Jacket - MI
Regular price $130.00
$130.00
MBW 1925 Hat
Regular price $42.00
$42.00
MBW Applique Garwood LS Tee
Regular price $56.00
$56.00
MBW Red Canoe Hat
Regular price $42.00
$42.00
MI - Jute & Leather Tote
Regular price $60.00
$60.00
MI Nautical Flag Sweatshirt - Navy
Regular price $62.00
$62.00
MI Nautical Flag Sweatshirt - Red
Regular price $62.00
$62.00
MICC Cookie Bike Tea Towel
Regular price $15.00
$15.00
Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Sea Salt
Regular price $9.00
$9.00
Oatmeal Raisin
Regular price $9.00
$9.00
Opal 1/4 Zip - MI
Regular price $115.00
$115.00
Peanut Butter
Regular price $9.00
$9.00
Premium Cookie Upcharge
Regular price $2.00
$2.00
Rev. Weave Crew Champ - MI
Regular price $78.00
$78.00
Snickerdoodle
Regular price $9.00
$9.00
Straight Down Optic 1/4 Zip - MI
Regular price $125.00
$125.00
Straight Down Swing Jacket - MI
Regular price $115.00
$115.00
Sugar Cookie
Regular price $9.00
$9.00
The Classic Gift Box
Regular price $45.00
$45.00
The Cottage Sweatshirt - Butter - MI
Regular price $56.00
$56.00
The Cottage Sweatshirt - Lake Blue - MI
Regular price $56.00
$56.00
Triple Chocoholic (New!)
Regular price $9.00
$9.00
Contact

Customer Service
(231) 373-7310

Email
info@mackinacislandcookieco.com

Locations

Mackinac Island
Arnold Transit Line
7271 Main St
Mackinac Island, MI 49757

Upper Peninsula
E.J. Mertaugh Boat Works
296 S Hessel Point Rd
Hessel, MI 49745

Legal
  • Shipping Policy
  • Refund Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
Follow Us!

Allergy Notice

Our cookies are made in a facility that processes wheat, dairy, eggs, peanuts, tree nuts, soy, and other allergens. Cross-contact may occur.

Please call us with any questions.

  • © 2026, Mackinac Island Cookie Co.
  • Powered by Shopify