Our Cookies
These are the cookies everyone talks about. Take your time and pick the ones calling your name.
Easter Basket - Preorder!
There's only one thing everybody loves more than a chocolate bunny, and that's a chocolate FUDGE bunny!
Easter baskets are packaged in our gift box with festive blue crinkle paper, a sticker and includes:
- One 1/2 lb of Mackinac Island Chocolate Fudge in our limited edition Easter Bunny mold with the cutest Mackinac Island Cookie Co grosgrain ribbon.
- Two Birthday Cookies: Sprinkle sugar cookies with homemade buttercream icing and cookie crumbles to top it all off packaged and sealed for freshness.
*Pre-Ordered Easter Boxes will ship 7-10 days prior to Easter to better ensure timely delivery.
*Limited quantities available
ORDER NOWOatmeal Raisin
She's not a regular Oatmeal Raisin Cookie. She's a cool Oatmeal Raisin Cookie. Because with a hint of molasses and warm spices she sets herself apart!
ORDER NOW
Peanut Butter
You know we believe in a classic! Which is why you can count on our Peanut Butter Cookie being absolutely perfect. A crisp edge and a chewy center? Say less! You'd have to be a little nutty not to love this one.
ORDER NOW
Dutch Chocolate Chunk
From the Dutch Girls with Love.
The three blonde bakers wanted to bring you something delightful from the motherland. And so, our best-selling Dutch Chocolate Chunk cookies were born. Using imported chunks in a perfectly gooey dough, baked to be the size of your head. They sell out daily in our Mackinac Island shop for a reason.
Mackinac Monster (New!)
This lil snack is basically high-power jet fuel. Need trail mix? Here's one that won't spill out of a bag! Glued together with peanut butter, oatmeal dough, and peppered with chocolate chips, M&Ms and salty twisty pretzels for the perfect pick me up!
ORDER NOW
Gluten Free Breakfast
Fear not, our gluten-free friends! We have come to save the world from dry crusty gluten-free cookies! Practically a health food, the mile long list of ingredients makes this cookie our best seller to gluten-frees and gluten freaks alike. It's sort of a granola bar? But better (thanks to butter).
It's got: GF flour (obviously), oats, peanut butter, chocolate chips, walnuts, cranberries, shredded coconut, and flax seeds!
Gluten Free Chocolate Chip (New!)
Gluten free but still so soft and chewy. Copious amounts of butter and sugar and vanilla make this cookie oh-so delicious. Not to mention all those semi-sweet chocolate chips to balance it out.
ORDER NOW
Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Sea Salt
Shelley's original cookie that started it all! A classic and the best for a reason. It's sweet, chocolatey, chewy and a little salty all at once.
ORDER NOW
Sugar Cookie
A rich, buttery, soft cookie sprinkled with sparkly sugar.
ORDER NOWCherry Chocolate Chunk
A cookie fit for Michigan in honor of Traverse City's famous cherries! Chocolate chunks pair perfectly with tart cherries mixed in our mocha dough. If a black forest gateau could be a cookie!
ORDER NOW
Snickerdoodle
Our zingy sugar cookie, rolled in cinnamon sugar and baked 'til the edges are crispy and the middle is gooey! If you love a snickerdoodle, you'll love this one (because it's 4x bigger than any other snickerdoodle you've ever seen).
ORDER NOW
Triple Chocoholic (New!)
Death by chocolate! With white chocolate chips, milk chocolate chips, Dutch chocolate chunks all mixed with our mocha dough, baked til it's fudgy in the middle.
ORDER NOW
Homemade Goodness
Homemade cookies the size of your head, espresso & coffee drinks, and nautically inspired gifts & apparel.
